The waters of Hawaii are beautiful with powerful waves replete with power. What better place for the U.S. military to explore the possibilities of wave power? The U.S. investment of $300 million is far short of the world’s leading countries investing in wave and tidal power, but few places are as ideal as this for exploring and advancing the wave power movement.
Off the coast of Hawaii, a tall buoy bobs and sways in the water, using the waves to generate electricity.The current travels through an undersea cable for a mile (1.6 km) to a military base, where it is fed into Oahu’s power grid — the first wave-produced electricity to go online in the U.S.
By some estimates, the ocean’s endless motion packs enough power to meet a quarter of America’s energy needs and dramatically reduce reliance on oil, gas and coal. But wave energy technology lags well behind those of wind and solar power, with important technical hurdles still to be overcome.
To that end, the U.S. Navy has established a test site in Hawaii, with hopes the technology can someday be used to produce clean, renewable power for offshore fueling stations for the fleet and provide electricity to coastal communities in fuel-starved places around the world.
“More power from more places translates to a more agile, more flexible, more capable force,” Joseph Bryan, Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Navy, said during an event at the site. “So we’re always looking for new ways to power the mission.”
Hawaii would seem a natural site for such technology. As any surfer can tell you, it is blessed with powerful waves. The island state also has the highest electricity costs in the nation — largely because of its heavy reliance on oil delivered by sea — and has a legislative mandate to get 100 percent of its energy from renewables by 2045.
Still, it could be 5 to 10 years before wave energy technology can provide an affordable alternative to fossil fuels, experts say.
For one thing, developers are still working to come up with the best design. Some buoys capture the up-and-down motion of the waves, while others exploit the side-to-side movement. Industry experts say a machine that uses all the ocean’s movements is most likely to succeed.
Also, the machinery has to be able to withstand powerful storms, the constant pounding of the seas and the corrosive effects of saltwater.
“The ocean is a really hard place to work,” said Patrick Cross, specialist at the Hawaii Natural Energy Institute at the University of Hawaii at Manoa, which helps run the Hawaii test site. “You’ve got to design something that can stay in the water for a long time.”
The U.S. has set a goal of reducing carbon emissions by one-third from 2005 levels by 2030, and many states are seeking to develop more renewable energy in the coming decades.
Jose Zayas, a director of the Wind and Water Power Technologies Office at the U.S. Department of Energy, which helps fund the Hawaii site, said the U.S. could get 20 to 28 percent of its energy needs from waves off the coasts without encroaching on sensitive waters such as marine preserves. “When you think about all of the states that have water along their coasts . . . there’s quite a bit of wave energy potential,” he said.
Wave energy technology is at about the same stage as the solar and wind industries were in the 1980s. Both received substantial government investment and tax credits that helped them become energy sources cheap enough to compete with fossil fuels.
The U.S. government and military have put about $334 million into marine energy research over the last decade, but Britain and the rest of Europe have invested more than $1 billion, according to the Marine Energy Council, a trade group. “We’re about, I’d say, a decade behind the Europeans,” said Alexandra De Visser, the navy’s Hawaii test site project manager.
The European Marine Energy Centre in Scotland, for example, has 14 grid-connected berths that have housed dozens of wave and tidal energy devices from around the world over the past 13 years, and Wave Hub in England has several such berths. China, too, has been building and testing dozens of units at sea.
Though small in scale, the test project near Kaneohe Bay represents the vanguard of U.S. wave energy development. It consists of two buoys anchored half a mile to a mile (0.8 to 1.6 km) off the coast.
One of them, the Azura, which stands 12 feet (3.6 meters) above the surface and extends 50 feet (15 meters) below, converts the waves’ vertical and horizontal movements into up to 18 kilowatts of electricity, enough for about a dozen homes. The company working with the Navy, Northwest Energy Innovations of Portland, Oregon, plans a version that can generate at least 500 kilowatts — enough to power hundreds of homes.
The other buoy, a 50-foot-wide, doughnut-shaped device called the Lifesaver, was developed by a Norwegian company. The 3-foot-tall ring is anchored to the ocean floor with cables; when the buoy is moved by the sea, the cables move, turning the wheels of a generator. It is producing just 4 kilowatts on average but is capable of generating more.
Test sites run by other researchers are being planned or expanded in Oregon and California to take advantage of the powerful waves that pound the West Coast. One of those projects, Cal Wave, run by California Polytechnic State University, hopes to provide utility-scale power to Vandenberg Air Force Base.
The Hawaii buoys are barely noticeable from shore without binoculars, but developers envision dozens of machines working all at once — an idea that could run into the same kind of opposition that wind turbines have faced from environmentalists, fishermen and tourist groups.
“Putting 200 machines on the North Shore of Oahu within a mile or two off the coast might be difficult, said Steve Kopf, CEO of Northwest Energy Innovations. “Nobody wants to look out and see wind turbines or wave machines off the coast.”